Download PDF A Trial by Jury, by D. Graham Burnett
Why ought to be this on-line e-book A Trial By Jury, By D. Graham Burnett You might not require to go someplace to read the e-books. You can read this publication A Trial By Jury, By D. Graham Burnett every single time and every where you really want. Even it remains in our spare time or sensation bored of the jobs in the office, this is right for you. Get this A Trial By Jury, By D. Graham Burnett right now and also be the quickest individual that completes reading this publication A Trial By Jury, By D. Graham Burnett
A Trial by Jury, by D. Graham Burnett
Download PDF A Trial by Jury, by D. Graham Burnett
A Trial By Jury, By D. Graham Burnett. Someday, you will discover a new experience and also understanding by investing more cash. But when? Do you think that you have to obtain those all needs when having significantly money? Why do not you attempt to obtain something simple at initial? That's something that will lead you to know even more about the world, experience, some places, history, amusement, as well as much more? It is your personal time to proceed reviewing routine. Among guides you could appreciate now is A Trial By Jury, By D. Graham Burnett here.
If you really want actually get the book A Trial By Jury, By D. Graham Burnett to refer currently, you have to follow this page always. Why? Keep in mind that you need the A Trial By Jury, By D. Graham Burnett resource that will provide you best requirement, do not you? By seeing this website, you have started to make new deal to always be updated. It is the first thing you can start to obtain all profit from being in a site with this A Trial By Jury, By D. Graham Burnett and also other collections.
From currently, locating the finished website that offers the finished books will be lots of, however we are the relied on website to see. A Trial By Jury, By D. Graham Burnett with very easy link, simple download, and also completed book collections become our better solutions to get. You can find as well as use the perks of picking this A Trial By Jury, By D. Graham Burnett as everything you do. Life is consistently developing and also you require some new publication A Trial By Jury, By D. Graham Burnett to be referral constantly.
If you still need a lot more publications A Trial By Jury, By D. Graham Burnett as referrals, going to search the title and also theme in this site is offered. You will find even more great deals publications A Trial By Jury, By D. Graham Burnett in various disciplines. You could additionally when possible to review guide that is currently downloaded and install. Open it and save A Trial By Jury, By D. Graham Burnett in your disk or gizmo. It will certainly ease you wherever you require the book soft file to read. This A Trial By Jury, By D. Graham Burnett soft documents to read can be reference for every person to improve the ability and capability.
When Princeton historian D. Graham Burnett answered his jury duty summons, he expected to spend a few days catching up on his reading in the court waiting room. Instead, he finds himself thrust into a high-pressure role as the jury foreman in a Manhattan trial. There he comes face to face with a stunning act of violence, a maze of conflicting evidence, and a parade of bizarre witnesses. But it is later, behind the closed door of the jury room, that he encounters the essence of the jury experience — he and eleven citizens from radically different backgrounds must hammer consensus out of confusion and strong disagreement. By the time he hands over the jury’s verdict, Burnett has undergone real transformation, not just in his attitude toward the legal system, but in his understanding of himself and his peers.
Offering a compelling courtroom drama and an intimate and sometimes humorous portrait of a fractious jury, A Trial by Jury is also a finely nuanced examination of law and justice, personal responsibility and civic duty, and the dynamics of power and authority between twelve equal people.
- Sales Rank: #491837 in Books
- Published on: 2002-10-15
- Released on: 2002-10-15
- Original language: English
- Number of items: 1
- Dimensions: 8.00" h x .43" w x 5.25" l, .49 pounds
- Binding: Paperback
- 208 pages
Amazon.com Review
Historian D. Graham Burnett writes about his experience as the foreman of the jury in a murder trial in New York City, what he calls "the most intense sixty-six hours of my life." There was nothing especially spectacular about the case; it was not a famous one, and while A Trial by Jury holds interest, it's not a John Grisham potboiler. Yet Burnett uses the experience to illuminate the heavy responsibilities of jury duty and all the maddening frustrations associated with determining something as deceptively simple as reasonable doubt.
"The jury room is a remarkable--and largely inaccessible--space in our society, a space where ideas, memories, virtues, and prejudices clash with the messy stuff of the big, bad world," Burnett writes in this elegant chronicle. His primary characters--his fellow jury members--come alive on these pages: "a clutch of strangers yelled, cursed, rolled on the floor, vomited, whispered, embraced, sobbed, and invoked both God and necromancy." He grows to like some, and "loathe" others. ("Are there some citizens not clearly able to distinguish daytime television from daily life?" he asks at one point.) Parts of the book are funny, as when he describes the small steps he took to encourage the trial lawyers to strike him out of the jury pool: "I promised to give any healthy prosecutor hives. I brought along a copy of The New York Review of Books just in case." Alas, Burnett found himself in the courtroom, and eventually he became foreman. This allows him to wrestle through the contradictory evidence presented by both sides--and forces him to conclude that even the truth can resemble a muddle when presented in court. He has trouble making up his own mind about the case--this is no Twelve Angry Men update, though its insights on jury-room dynamics are just as instructive. Burnett also ruminates on his own profession: "I realize now that for me--a humanist, an academic, a poetaster--the primary aim of sustained thinking and talking had always been, in a way, more thinking and talking. Cycles of reading, interpreting, and discussing were always exactly that: cycles. One never 'solved' a poem, one read it, and then read it again--each reading emerging from earlier efforts and preparing the mind for future readings." Jury duty, of course, demands an awesome finality--and the conclusion to the trial involving Burnett is one that haunts the author after the gavel falls. --John Miller
From Publishers Weekly
Combining an ethical examination of civic obligation with a meticulous character study, Princeton historian of science Burnett (Masters of All They Surveyed) dramatizes his experience of being selected for jury duty in a capital case. Told as two parts of the same tale (trial and jury deliberations), the story is appropriately navigated between several Scylla-and-Charybdis pairings the court and the jury room, the truth and lies of the case, the application of laws and the fiery desire for justice. While the murder trial delves into sordid details of transvestism, male prostitution and rape, the tale takes its potent turn when Burnett is unexpectedly moved into the position of jury foreman (the original foreman simply disappeared one day) and must play a critical role in the jury deliberations. Holding other jurors' wide-ranging emotions in check while staying focused on the case himself, Burnett ultimately brings readers face-to-face with the stultifying bureaucracy of American law in praxis. Drawing on an academic and intellectual background, he builds an impressive melodrama and tense, emotionally exhausting scenes in the jury room that surely will recall Twelve Angry Men. But while the ruminations are articulate and engrossing, readers may wonder how Burnett plays a key role in the story while managing to remain distant enough to render the facts of the jury room as easily as he does. (Sept. 19)Forecast: Knopf is taking a big position on this, with a first printing of 100,000, a 10-city author tour and national advertising on CNN and Court TV, where Burnett will also make appearances. If he comes across as personable, his glimpse behind the closed doors of justice could tempt a wide range of curious readers.
Copyright 2001 Cahners Business Information, Inc.
From Library Journal
A young scholar with a one-year fellowship at a prestigious New York City learning institution suddenly finds his quiet, bookish life interrupted by jury duty in Manhattan. Burnett (history, Princeton) chronicles his own path from ordinary citizen and prospective juror, to seated juror, to jury foreman, to peacemaker, and, finally, to resolution artist as he uses his own unique blend of knowledge and reason to lead 11 other disparate souls to a unanimous verdict. The book offers rare, insightful views inside a jury room, as people from all walks of life try to work together and reach a consensus. The case at hand involves a complex blend of seduction and murder, with the defendant claiming he killed the victim in self-defense after being pressured for sex. What emerges from the author's leadership of the deliberations is his attempt to build a consensus through a unique blend of patience, knowledge, and wisdom intrinsic to the rigor and discipline of classical and academic thought processes. Burnett reminds us how imperfect the adversarial system of law really is, and the narrative format allows for a rapid and enjoyable overview of the topic. Recommended for academic and public libraries.
- Philip Y. Blue, New York State Supreme Court Criminal Branch Lib., New York
Copyright 2001 Reed Business Information, Inc.
Most helpful customer reviews
11 of 14 people found the following review helpful.
The idea is great; the author, case and jury are less so
By P. Meltzer
The idea for this book was certainly a good one. Given how the whole jury system plays such a central role in our judicial system, it is rather surprising that there is so little material on what actually goes in inside the jury room. As Burnett rightly points out, it is a "largely inaccessible space in our society." Thus the book is certainly a step towards filling that void. That said, I found it somewhat unsatisfying for several reasons, some of them within the author's control and some of them not.
In various other reviews here, the author has been described variously as "pretentious" (on several occasions), "pompous", "snobbish", "holier-than thou", "smug", and "self-congratulatory". Anyone see a theme here? I don't really disagree with any of these and I would add pedantic, condescending and superior. It really comes through on almost every page. And yet, I have to say that with the possible exception of Adelle, no one else in that jury room seemed like a candidate for MENSA. In fact, a number of them, such as Felipe and Rachel, seemed like true idiots.
The overall lack of intelligence of so many jury members had several unfortunate consequences. First, with just a few exceptions, including some comments by Adelle and Dean, it made the deliberations (which take up half of the book) much less interesting than they otherwise might have been. Second, whatever sense of pedantry and superiority which is probably naturally latent in the author anyway were probably brought to the fore when he saw who he was dealing with.
Also, again though no fault of the author's, I simply didn't find the case he had to work with all that riveting. A man was lured to or went voluntarily to the apartment of some sort of man/woman/transvestite/cross-dresser/drag queen and either did or did not kill the latter in self-defense when the latter made sexual advances.
All in all, it was not a bad book by any means, but I don't think that it was the book it could have been either.
7 of 10 people found the following review helpful.
A Refreshing Insight
By Roger D. Thome
Many of us can think the thoughts, but few of us can put into words the experience of sitting on a jury and interacting with our fellow man in order to attain a "just" verdict. D. Graham Burnett has taken this mandatory life experience and shed a new light on it and now shares it with the world. Having been associated with the legal process, as a court reporter, for 30 years, and having, for the most part, taken it for granted, it was very refreshing for me to see, through his eyes, its shortcomings and its strengths. He asks tough questions. What is the law? What is a just verdict? How powerful is the state? Do we need protection from it? And, he demonstrates just how the jury process can and does work, even with all of the personalities, the loss of patience, the bickering of strong-willed people, and how even the quiet and withdrawn have something to say: eventually. Well worth your time.
7 of 9 people found the following review helpful.
Could have been better
By John Harrison
It is easy to pick on people that are less educated than you, and, if you are very well educated like this author, to do it in a way that seems less than mean spirited, however real people are difficult to understand and this is what the book unfortunately missed. The author approaches his subject "critically" rather than with curiosity. Because of his intelligance, his education, his experiance, etc., he obviously feels that he "knows" what he is talking about. And, about many things, some of which are in this flawed book, this is true. But, he could have learned many things and this is the problem with the book. While as a trial lawyer I found the book useful, I would hesitate to say that I also found it to be good.
A Trial by Jury, by D. Graham Burnett PDF
A Trial by Jury, by D. Graham Burnett EPub
A Trial by Jury, by D. Graham Burnett Doc
A Trial by Jury, by D. Graham Burnett iBooks
A Trial by Jury, by D. Graham Burnett rtf
A Trial by Jury, by D. Graham Burnett Mobipocket
A Trial by Jury, by D. Graham Burnett Kindle
Tidak ada komentar:
Posting Komentar